SOUTH BEND, Ind. — Mayor Pete Buttigieg took a third day off from the campaign trail on Wednesday to confront a crisis over the fatal police shooting of a black resident of South Bend, Ind.Mr. Buttigieg said he was “extremely frustrated” that the white officer’s body camera was switched off at the time.
The shooting of the 54-year-old man revived longstanding mistrust by some black residents of the city police and of Mr. Buttigieg, and it has presented the mayor, a Democratic presidential candidate, with a national leadership test just a week before the first primary debates.
The case has revived scrutiny of Mr. Buttigieg’s history of sometimes strained relations with African-Americans in South Bend. The issue is echoing in the Democratic primary as Mr. Buttigieg, 37, seeks to improve his support with black voters.
[18 questions. 21 Democrats. Here’s what they said.]
After addressing a half-dozen newly sworn-in officers — all white — on Wednesday morning, Mr. Buttigieg, the son of two Notre Dame professors, acknowledged to reporters outside police headquarters that he had only a “theoretical” understanding of the charged issue of race and policing when he took office nearly eight years ago.
“I’ve learned about how raw these issues are,” he said. “I’ve learned that this is a mix of not only distant historical issues, but of things happening around us every day.”
[Sign up for our politics newsletter and join the conversation about the 2020 presidential race.]
In his speech to the new recruits, Mr. Buttigieg stressed that everyone in uniform is “burdened” with the history of racial injustice between the police and minority communities,which has lately been heightened by what Mr. Buttigieg called “a seemingly constant series of stories and videos from around the country showing abuses that tarnish the badge and fuel mistrust.”
Mr. Buttigieg also held a news conference with black community leaders at South Bend’s Civil Rights Heritage Center on Wednesday afternoon.
The president of the South Bend N.A.A.C.P., Michael Patton, said he thought the city was rising to the challenge of dealing with a disturbing incident. “We need one another and all of us are valuable in our community,” he said.
Mr. Buttigieg said his efforts to meet with family members of the dead man had been rebuffed on advice of a lawyer they had hired. The lawyer, Brian W. Coffman, said in an interview that he planned to file a federal civil rights lawsuit against the city and the officer, noting that the officer’s failure to use his body camera was suspicious. “That raises a big flare for me and anyone who does civil rights cases,” he said.
[Read about Pete Buttigieg’s complicated history with African-Americans and the police.]
For many black voters in South Bend, issues of personal safety and policing are the most visceral way they perceive elected officials.
“How many people judge a mayor in the African-American community is how you handle your police department,” Oliver Davis, a black member of the South Bend City Council who has criticized Mr. Buttigieg, said Tuesday.
Mr. Davis said minority groups’ trust in South Bend police officers — only 10 percent of whom are black or Hispanic — was low. That mistrust has inflamed suspicions about the events that led to the shooting early Sunday morning of Eric Logan by a white officer.
Court records show that the officer, Sgt. Ryan O’Neill, has previously been accused of using racially charged language and excessive force against black suspects.
Mr. O’Neill, a 19-year veteran of the department, was twice sued in 2008 by black residents he had arrested, court records show. Both suits, filed in federal court on forms provided to the jailed suspects, were dismissed when the men did not pay filing fees to continue.
A former South Bend police officer, David Newton, complained to superiors in 2008 that Mr. O’Neill had made derogatory remarks about interracial relationships and “black meat” to another officer. A spokesman for the South Bend Police Department, Ken Garcia, said Tuesday that an internal investigation found that Mr. Newton’s assertion was “not sustained.”
The police union did not respond to requests for comment from Mr. O’Neill.
According to the authorities, Mr. O’Neill shot and killed Mr. Logan while responding to a report of someone breaking into cars downtown. Mr. O’Neill responded without using his lights and sirens, which would automatically have triggered his body camera. Nor did Mr. O’Neill turn on the camera manually when he exited the police car. Mr. O’Neill shot Mr. Logan once in the abdomen after he refused to drop a knife when Mr. O’Neill ordered him to do so, the authorities said.
Late Tuesday, Mr. Buttigieg issued an order that all officers must activate their body cameras in all working interactions with civilians. He said the reasons Mr. O’Neill’s was not on would be examined in an internal affairs review, which would follow an investigation by the county prosecutor of whether charges are warranted against Mr. O’Neill.
South Bend purchased body cameras under Mr. Buttigieg and implemented bias training for officers, among other measures designed to increase community trust of the police.
The efforts stem from Mr. Buttigieg’s firing of the city’s first black police chief in 2012, which Mr. Buttigieg acknowledged created a yearslong rift with African-Americans in South Bend.
Get more stuff like this
Subscribe to our mailing list and get interesting stuff and updates to your email inbox.